Skip to main content

Netherlands vs Denmark (WHO WILL WIN?)

Showdown of the century! Which country has the best bicycle infrastructure?! The answer is finally here! And the winner is……… neither! Or, it depends.

The systems have many similarities and differences and which one is better comes down to personal preference around infrastructure type and riding style. My observations regarding differences are

Denmark
  • More consistent infrastructure styles
  • Stricter cycling rules and norms
  • Danish left
  • Blue route demarking
  • More "organized"
  • Less volume of cyclists
  • More distinct routes
The Netherlands
  • Diverse types of bike infrastructure
  • Dutch red
  • Bicycles and pedestrians on the same grade
  • More shared spaces between pedestrians and bicycles
  • High volume traffic
  • Infrastructure designed for bike volume at intersections
  • The network seems more complete
As Ronald pointed out, historical context is key when discussing the differences between infrastructure. Copenhagen had a huge fire, forcing them to rebuild, whereas Amsterdam has to work around increasingly aging infrastructure and streets, some of which are medieval. My own personal preference is for Amsterdam. The famous Dutch flow makes sense to me as a cyclist. People adapt quickly and the infrastructure is designed to keep bikes moving with rounded turns. The infrastructure in Amsterdam feels like it was designed for bikes and cyclists, whereas Copenhagen felt more like a retrofitted car infrastructure and still limited (I really disliked the Danish left turn).

One distinction I would make is it feels more convenient in Amsterdam to bike, but safer in Copenhagen. I believe this is largely due to not being used to the volume of cyclists in the Netherlands and the narrow cobblestone streets. These streets are not the most comfortable thing to ride on but do help preserve the historic character of the city. Another aspect of the Netherlands that I like is transit seems to be equally invested in across types. In Amsterdam, I found it easy to walk, bike, or take public transit places. In Copenhagen, walking could be longer than necessary and take you down roads that didn't feel as safe as pedestrian safety in the Netherlands. The transit system in Amsterdam feels more interconnected compared to Copenhagens. One example is the Oviefiets and the relationship between biking and public transit in the city.

Comparing the two systems emphasizes how prioritization of humans over cars and thinking outside of the auto industry capitalist box when it comes to transit can create sustainable, accessible, safe, convenient, and enjoyable transit systems. While I personally liked the Dutch model better, I think the Danish model would be a better starting point in most American cities. However, every US city is different and I believe that different aspects of each model would fit in better in some American cities compared to others. One specific example came to me while debriefing the PUMA activity with Meredith. Her figure depicting distance to transit stations by walking vs by bike, which rapidly expanded infrastructure access, made me analyze how accessible the transit stations by my childhood home are. I am fortunate enough to live across the street from a TriMet bus line but the park and ride MAX station I use is almost only reachable by car and has limited bike parking. Improving the bike infrastructure in that area and connecting the existing (limited) network in the Portland Metro to the transit stations would increase people's access to the whole metro, without the need for cars. 
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Cities for Kids Part 2.

In my short time in Malmö, I have noticed significantly fewer playgrounds and spaces for children compared to Copenhagen. You’d think in a less dense city with more dedication to green space, there would be more playgrounds but alas. However, in my walking journey today for souvenirs, a raincoat, and chocolate, I wandered into an exhibit in a square called Dröm Torg (Dream Square). This empty square, half was taken up by a surface parking lot, featured art by children of what they imagined as their “Dream Square”. This exhibit showed squares filled with trees, flowers, bushes, playgrounds, and an occasional snake or clown. They’re was also a common theme of readily available ice cream near the square in the children's drawings. I really enjoyed this exhibit, and hope it is more than just an exhibit and actually comes to fruition. Not just engaging children with society through safe public spaces, but engaging them with the creation of the space, is a great way to incorporate them i...
1 comment
Read more

Ode to Museums

I am a huge fan of solo travel and typically travel by myself or with my family or a small group of friends. I’ve enjoyed traveling with our large group but it’s been an adjustment and it’s been helpful to take time for myself and take solo adventures. While in Copenhagen I visited the Jewish Museum and Glyptoteket by myself and used my bicycle as a means of transportation. Solo bicycling in a city where I was unfamiliar helped me adjust quickly to the customs and the routes in the areas I was in. Both museums had a very in-depth architectural history. The attention to architecture, both interior and exterior in Denmark seemed significantly more than in the US. I noticed similar architectural patterns in Amsterdam, where my solo museum journey via bike continued. I went to the Anne Frank House with a group and the Van Gogh, the Portuguese Synagogue, and the Jewish Museum by myself. The architecture in Amsterdam is much more influenced by its medieval roots and existing infrastructure, ...
1 comment
Read more

Cities for Kids and Bikes

  A common theme in my reflections has been the mixing of ages in public spaces and the abundance of children on bikes. In addition to safe bicycle infrastructure, Copenhagen has facilitated a city for kids through access to playgrounds, courtyards, parks, and a general whimsy in the city. The parks and playgrounds in Copenhagen were abundant and I found the concept of a manned/staffed playground really interesting. Dedicating staffing and money to playgrounds is a very foreign concept to me since child development and joy are not invested in the United States outside of the school system (and even then…). The traffic garden showed a deep care and investment in child joy and safety I found refreshing and inspiring. In addition to the various playgrounds I found, I also documented micro-playgrounds or places for play and playgrounds in more mature locations (such as museums). This showed how integrated children and their activities are into all aspects of Danish life.  The Dani...
1 comment
Read more